Most owners keep a bad agency about six months too long.

Not because they're fooled. Because switching is a hassle, the reports look busy and nobody can say for sure whether the marketing is working. The agency counts on that.

Here's how I'd decide, and ten questions to ask before you pay the next invoice.

First, don't fire them for the wrong reason

Some agencies are fine and the problem is somewhere else. Before you blame the agency, check what happens to a lead after it arrives.

Sometimes lead volume grows and the relationship still ends because revenue doesn't follow. Often the ads are doing their job and the problem is what happens at the front desk: calls unanswered, slow callbacks, no follow-up on quotes. Firing the agency doesn't fix that. If your leads are going into a hole, a new agency will fill the same hole.

So test your own side first. How fast do you respond? How many calls go to voicemail? If the answers are bad, read my lead response rule before you make a change.

The ten questions

Send these in writing and see what comes back.

  1. How many of last month's leads became paid jobs? Not leads. Jobs. If they can't answer, they aren't tracking what matters. See cost per lead vs cost per job.
  2. Which source produced each of those jobs? Real attribution connects an ad click or a call to revenue. Marketing attribution for small business explains how.
  3. Are closed jobs sent back to Google Ads as conversions? If not, the platform optimizes for form fills, not customers. See Google Ads offline conversions.
  4. Who owns the accounts? Ad accounts, analytics, call tracking, Google Business Profile, the domain and the website host should all be in your name, with you as admin.
  5. Can I see the raw data, not a PDF? A dashboard you can open yourself is worth more than a monthly deck.
  6. What did you change last month, and why? Good agencies keep a change log. Vague answers like "optimized campaigns" aren't answers.
  7. What are you testing next, and what result would make you stop? If there's no hypothesis, there's no learning.
  8. What's my cost per lead trend, and what's the lead quality trend? Cost alone says nothing. Ask how they define a bad lead and how many they've filtered out.
  9. What's in the fee? Management, ad spend and any markup or platform fees should be itemized.
  10. If I leave, what do I keep? Creative, landing pages, tracking setups, audience lists and account history should transfer cleanly.

What the answers tell you

  • You get numbers and a plan. Keep them. Ask for a tighter reporting format and a check-in date.
  • You get activity but no outcome. Impressions, clicks, "engagement" and traffic reports are inputs. Give them one quarter to connect to jobs, with a written target.
  • You get defensiveness or silence. That's an answer.
  • You find you don't control your accounts. Fix that before anything else.

Red flags that mean act now

  • They won't give you admin access, or the accounts are in the agency's name.
  • Reports change format every month.
  • They can't explain a fee or a spend line.
  • Leads are rising and you can't tell whether any are real.
  • Every problem is solved by a bigger budget.
  • Cancellation requires a long notice period or penalty you didn't expect. Check your contract.

How long to give them

It depends on the channel. Paid search can show a pattern in a couple of months if the budget is meaningful and tracking is in place. Local search and content take longer. What you shouldn't accept is an open-ended "it takes time."

Set a review date at the start of any engagement. On that date, three things should be on the table: what was promised, what the numbers show and what changes next. If the numbers are weak but the agency can show you why, with data and a specific fix, that's a conversation. If the answer is a new tactic every month with no connection to jobs, you're paying for experiments with your money.

Also check the ask against the evidence. A client who wants a hundred new customers a month from a modest budget, in a market where the cost per click is high, is setting up any agency to fail. A good one tells you that on day one. A bad one signs you anyway.

Ownership is the whole game

A pattern worth checking for: when a new agency comes in, the previous one is holding the domain, the call tracking number, the business profile or the ad account. Every handoff becomes a recovery project that takes weeks and costs the business visibility while it's sorted out. Nothing technical caused it. Nobody asked who owned what at the start.

Before you fire anyone, get the access. Get admin on every account, written confirmation of where each asset lives and a transition plan. Then give notice.

What a fair exit looks like

Be specific about why you're leaving. Send a short written note: the goals you agreed to, what the numbers show and the date you'll end the contract. Ask for a handover call and a document that lists every account, login owner and campaign setting. Stay professional. Agencies talk, but more importantly, a clean exit gets you the files and access you need on day one of the next arrangement.

If you fire them, then what?

Decide first whether you're moving to another agency, hiring in-house or doing a lighter version yourself. In-house vs agency marketing covers the trade-offs. And write down what "working" means before you start the next engagement: leads, booked jobs, cost per job, a date to review. Put it in the contract, not just the kickoff call. The next agency should know on day one exactly what number they're being judged on, and so should you.

If you want an outside read on what your current reports are actually telling you, start with Di-Hy's free audit.