A $40 lead that never books costs more than a $200 lead that does.
That sounds obvious until you look at the report your agency sends. Most of them lead with cost per lead, because it's the number they control and the one that looks best. The number that pays your bills is cost per job.
The difference in one line
- Cost per lead is ad spend divided by the number of form fills and calls.
- Cost per job is ad spend divided by the number of leads that turned into paid work.
The gap between them is your close rate. And your close rate isn't something your ads control. It depends on lead quality, how fast you respond and how well you quote.
A worked example
These numbers are made up to show the math. They aren't from a client. Swap in yours.
| Campaign A | Campaign B | |
|---|---|---|
| Ad spend | $2,000 | $2,000 |
| Leads | 50 | 10 |
| Cost per lead | $40 | $200 |
| Leads that became jobs | 2 | 4 |
| Cost per job | $1,000 | $500 |
Campaign A looks five times better on the report. Campaign B wins on the metric that matters, by half. Campaign A is probably pulling in the wrong people: price shoppers, wrong service area, spam, curiosity clicks. Campaign B pulls fewer, better leads.
Now put revenue on it. If an average job is worth $3,000 and you keep a margin on it, Campaign A's 2 jobs and Campaign B's 4 jobs are a very different month, for the same spend.
Why the cheap lead is usually the bad lead
Platforms optimize for whatever you tell them to count. If a form fill is the conversion, the system finds the people most likely to fill out forms, not the people most likely to buy. Cheap leads are often cheap because they're easy to get, and they're easy to get because they aren't serious.
I go deeper on this in why Google Ads leads are low quality.
What to track instead
You need four numbers, and you can get them from a spreadsheet:
- Leads by source.
- Booked (quote or appointment held).
- Won (paid job).
- Revenue from won jobs, by the source that brought the lead.
From those you get cost per booked appointment, cost per job and return on spend. If your CRM can't tell you which source a job came from, that's the first fix. The full system is in marketing attribution for small business.
Don't forget the leak after the lead
Some of the gap between cost per lead and cost per job isn't the ad at all. It's a missed call, a slow callback or a quote nobody chased. Volume can rise while revenue doesn't follow, because the front office isn't converting what comes in. That's a follow-up problem, and it's usually cheaper to fix than buying more leads. See my lead response rule and why an old customer list is an asset.
One-line test
Ask your agency or whoever runs your ads: "How many of last month's leads became paid jobs, and what did each cost?" If they can't answer, you're buying leads, not jobs. If you want help setting that up, start with Di-Hy's free audit.