Deposits are not revenue. The seller's statement is not the seller's business.
A profit and loss statement is a document someone prepared. It can be accurate, it can be optimistic and it can be wrong by accident. Your job before you pay for a business is to trace each number to a record the seller didn't write.
This is the order I work in. It's the same method I describe in how to buy a small business, narrowed to the financials.
Start by recomputing, not reading
Don't read the broker's summary. Rebuild it.
Take the headline earnings figure and work it from the raw lines yourself: revenue, cost of goods sold, expenses, owner pay, add-backs. Then compare.
A number presented as earnings can really be the sum of the add-back rows. It isn't earnings at all. That's rare, but the pattern isn't: a headline number that nobody has recomputed since the broker pasted it in. Check it first, because everything downstream hangs off it.
Watch for small tells:
- Negative entries in cost of goods sold. They inflate gross profit and can decide whether a year was profitable.
- Totals that don't foot. If a balance sheet shows negative total liabilities, stop underwriting off it.
- Account names read literally. An account called something like "unreceived inventory" means the goods aren't in the building.
- Round numbers in places that shouldn't be round.
Tax returns first, bank statements second, P&L last
The order matters because each source is harder for the seller to shape than the one after it.
- Tax returns. Ask for several years, complete, with all schedules. Read past page one. On a corporate or partnership return, the balance sheet schedule should agree with the capital account reconciliation and the owners' K-1s. When they disagree, don't assume missing money. It's often a preparer's data entry error, and the documents that agree with each other usually point to which line is wrong. But you have to ask.
- Bank statements. Every account, every month, covering the same periods as the returns.
- The P&L and any broker book. Last, because it's the version someone has already edited.
Lenders do a version of this too. Form 4506-C lets an approved third party get tax transcripts directly from the IRS, so you can compare what the seller handed you to what was filed. The IRS publishes the form and instructions. If you're using SBA financing, ask your lender what they'll pull and when.
Do a proof of cash
This is the check that closes the gap between the paper and the money. The idea is simple: revenue on the books should reconcile to deposits in the bank.
- Total the deposits for a period.
- Remove transfers between the seller's own accounts, loan proceeds, owner contributions and refunds.
- Add back cash that was received but not deposited, if the business takes any.
- Compare the result to reported revenue.
If revenue is $1.2M on the return and clean deposits are $1.0M, something needs an explanation. If deposits are well above revenue, you also need to understand why: sales tax collected, customer deposits, pass-through costs or money from somewhere else.
The reverse case matters just as much. A business that takes meaningful cash and doesn't deposit it creates numbers you can't verify, and a lender or buyer can only credit what's documented. Whatever the story, it has to tie.
Check the tax side separately
Sales tax is where small businesses most often borrow from themselves. Compare sales tax collected to sales tax payable on the balance sheet, and ask for proof of what was remitted. In Florida, unpaid sales tax can follow the assets to a buyer under Florida Statutes 213.758. Ask for the Department of Revenue's actual certificate of compliance, not a receipt for a request. Get your attorney and CPA to confirm what applies to your structure.
Walk it and match it
The paper should match the place. If the P&L says one thing about equipment, inventory or headcount, look at the shop, the yard or the payroll register. If the asset list leaves out half of what you see in the building, you've learned something about how the books were kept. Photograph and date everything before the deal closes.
Third-party checks that don't depend on the seller
- Payroll records against reported wages and headcount.
- Customer concentration: ask for revenue by customer and look at the top five.
- Licenses and registrations through the state's public lookups.
- Insurance quotes, which come from someone with no stake.
- Your own CPA, paid by you.
A quality of earnings review from an independent accountant is worth the cost on larger deals, and some lenders may require one at higher purchase prices. Ask your lender where their threshold sits under the current SBA rules, in writing.
When to walk
You don't need fraud to walk away. You need a gap that can't be explained with a document. If the answer to "why don't these two numbers match?" is a story and not a record, price in the risk or leave.
If you want a second set of eyes on your method, see how I approach acquisition diligence. For the add-back side, read SDE add-backs explained, and for what a listing doesn't tell you, broker listing red flags.
FAQ
What documents should I ask a seller for?
Several years of full tax returns with all schedules, matching bank statements for every account, payroll records, a sales tax compliance record, customer revenue by account and the asset list.
What is a proof of cash?
A reconciliation of reported revenue to actual bank deposits after removing transfers, loans and other non-revenue items. It shows whether the books match the money.
Are bank statements or tax returns more reliable?
Neither is complete alone. Bank statements are hard to shape, and tax returns show what was reported to the IRS. You need both to agree.
Do I still need a lawyer?
Yes. Counsel handles title, liens and the contract. Reading the financials is operator work that makes the lawyer's job narrower.
Sources: IRS Form 4506-C, Florida Statutes 213.758, SBA 7(a) loans. SBA rules change, and lenders read them differently. Get your lender's position in writing.