A broker's listing is an advertisement. Read it like one.

That isn't a knock on brokers. Many are honest, and a packaged book saves a buyer real time. But the document is written to sell the business, by someone paid when it sells. Your job is to read it as the other side of that.

Here are the red flags I look for, in the order I usually hit them. The examples are generalized, with all specifics stripped out. Each flag isn't a reason to walk away. It's a reason to ask a better question. For the full process around this, start with how to buy a small business.

Red flags in the teaser

The teaser is the one-page summary that goes out before the NDA. It tells you what the broker wants you to believe.

  • "Absentee-run" or "runs itself." Ask who the owner talks to every day, and who the customers call. Many "absentee" businesses are one person's phone.
  • "Recession-proof." No business is. Ask what happened to revenue in the last downturn, and what it did in the last twelve months.
  • A revenue figure with no period. Annual? Trailing twelve months? Best year? An unlabeled number is usually the best one.
  • Cash flow with no definition. Seller's discretionary earnings, EBITDA and net income are three different numbers. If the teaser doesn't say which, it's the biggest of the three.
  • "Motivated seller" and "must sell." It's sales copy. It tells you nothing you can use.

Red flags in the financial summary

This is where I spend most of my time.

The headline number isn't what the line items add up to

Recompute every figure from the rows underneath it. A number labeled as earnings can really be the total of the add-back rows. The actual net income was a small fraction. You only find that by doing the arithmetic yourself.

The add-backs are doing too much work

Add-backs adjust earnings for expenses that wouldn't continue under a new owner. The legitimate ones are the owner's own salary, personal expenses run through the business and genuine one-time costs. Warning signs:

  • Adding back all wages, when only the owner's should come out. The employees still have to be paid after closing.
  • Recurring "one-time" costs that show up every year.
  • Add-backs with no document behind them. If the seller can't show the expense, ask why it's an add-back.
  • A long list of small items that together make up most of the earnings figure.

I go through this in SDE add-backs explained.

Odd entries in cost of goods sold

A negative line in cost of goods sold inflates gross profit. One entry like that can turn a losing year into a profitable one. Ask what it is and what document supports it.

Balance sheet accounts that say what they mean

Read the account names literally. An account called "unreceived inventory" means goods that aren't in the building. If that account is larger than the inventory you can walk past, you've found the real conversation. And if total liabilities come out negative or the balance sheet doesn't balance, stop underwriting off that document. It's wrong somewhere, and you don't yet know where.

A single good year

Look for at least three years, and ask what drove any jump. A business whose earnings doubled the year it went on the market needs an explanation that isn't "we got busy."

"Pro forma" and "run rate"

These are projections dressed as history. A run rate takes a strong month and multiplies it. A pro forma assumes things the business hasn't done. I'm not saying ignore them. I'm saying they aren't earnings, and the price shouldn't be built on them.

Red flags in what's missing

Absence tells you as much as presence.

  • No tax returns offered, or only "summaries." Returns are what the seller actually told the IRS. They need to be compared to the books, including the schedules behind the first page.
  • No customer breakdown. If one or two customers are a large share of revenue, that's the risk you're buying. A book that doesn't mention concentration usually has some.
  • No balance sheet, or only a profit and loss statement.
  • No mention of licenses, permits or key contracts. Trade and professional licenses often belong to a person, not the company. See buying a trades business.
  • Vague reason for selling. "Ready to retire" is fine and common. "Pursuing other opportunities" with no detail deserves a follow-up.
  • No asset list, or a list that looks too clean. Walk the property yourself. Asset lists often leave things off.

Red flags in how the process runs

  • Pressure to move before you've seen records. Deadlines that exist to stop you doing diligence aren't real deadlines.
  • Refusing to provide primary documents. A bank statement, a utility bill, a tax notice. These are normal requests.
  • Real estate bundled in without separate figures. The building and the business are two deals. Ask for them priced separately.
  • Answers that change. If the explanation for a number shifts between conversations, the number isn't known.
  • "Everyone else is interested." Maybe. It's also the oldest line in sales.

Check whether your sources are independent

When three places agree, it feels like confirmation. Check whether they're independent. A broker's book, a listing site and a directory can all repeat one stale record. One error shown three times is still one error. I'd ask for a primary document, like a bank statement or tax notice, to settle it.

What to do with a red flag

A red flag is a question, not a verdict. I use one filter before anything goes to the seller or broker: does the answer change the price, my ability to close, or a risk that survives the purchase? If it does, I ask, in writing, and keep the answer. If it doesn't, it's curiosity, and I keep it to myself.

Ten sharp questions get better answers than forty scattered ones. And when a seller can't or won't answer the ones that matter, that is your answer.

Finally, a bank statement isn't a P&L, and deposits aren't revenue. More on how to check the numbers independently in how to verify a seller's financials.

If you own a business and you're thinking about selling directly, without a broker's book, I'd like to hear from you. Start on my acquisition page.

FAQ

What is a CIM in business sales?

A confidential information memorandum is the detailed book a broker gives qualified buyers after an NDA. It covers the business, financials and operations. It is a sales document, so every number in it needs to be checked against records.

How do I know if a broker's numbers are real?

Recompute the headline figures from the line items, then compare the books to tax returns and bank statements. If a number can't be traced to a document, treat it as a claim.

Should I walk away over one red flag?

Not usually. Ask the question and see how the seller responds. Several unanswered flags, or a refusal to provide basic documents, is a better reason to stop.


Note: This post is method and opinion, not legal or financial advice. Confirm specifics with your lender, accountant and attorney.