Your cheapest customers are the ones who already asked you for help.
They filled out a form, called for a quote or booked once and never came back. Somebody paid to get them in the door. Then the follow-up stopped, and they sit in a CRM or a spreadsheet doing nothing. This is my opinion on why that list matters more than most owners treat it. For the step-by-step method, read Di-Hy's guide: How to Reactivate Old Customers in a Trades Business.
My position
I treat a dormant customer list as an asset, even though it never shows up on a balance sheet. The business already paid to build it. Letting it go cold is like leaving equipment in a yard.
It also shapes how I look at a business as a buyer. When I ask a seller for the customer list, I'm checking two things. Does it exist in a clean, usable form? And does anyone ever contact it? A company with ten years of customers and no list is a company that has been spending on acquisition and throwing away the results.
The two rules I'd follow before touching it
1. Know how each person agreed to hear from you. Email falls under the CAN-SPAM Act. Texts are stricter, and the rules have been changing, so ask your attorney what your consent records have to show before you text any list. My test is simple: can you point to when and how each person gave you their number? If not, start with email or a phone call and fix how you collect consent going forward.
2. Count a win only when you can trace it. A customer who was going to call anyway doesn't count. A reply isn't a booking, and a booking isn't revenue until the job is done and paid. Measure cost per booked job, not cost per reply.
What I would not do
I wouldn't blast the whole list with a discount. It teaches people to wait for a coupon. I wouldn't message a list you bought. And I wouldn't start before someone is assigned to answer replies the same day, because a reply is a live lead.
The trade-off
Reactivation is cheap, and that is exactly why it gets done badly. It's easy to send something sloppy to people who once trusted you, and you only get a few chances before they stop opening. I'd rather send a small, careful batch, read every reply and fix what's confusing before sending more.
I'm also not going to quote reactivation or booking rates. The numbers floating around mostly come from companies selling the software, and I don't have a sourced figure to put next to them.
If you want someone to look at your list and your follow-up with you, Di-Hy's free audit is where I'd start.
FAQ
Is a dormant customer list worth anything?
To the business, yes. It's customers who already know you, which is cheaper to reach than strangers. Whether it's worth contacting depends on how clean it is and whether people agreed to hear from you.
Is it legal to text old leads?
Marketing texts generally need prior express written consent under the TCPA, and the rules are changing. Confirm your consent records with an attorney before texting any list.
Sources: FTC CAN-SPAM compliance guide, FCC Consumer Policy Division. This isn't legal advice. For the full how-to, see Di-Hy's reactivation guide.